Regardless of where it came from, pimento cheese is a regional favorite for a reason. Add in the pimentos and stir until combined. Instructions. To make this a grilled pimento cheese sandwich spread tablespoon of butter on each slice of bread. cream cheese, softened 1/4 cup kosher or sea salt, freshly cracked 1/4 cup black pepper, freshly cracked 1/4 cup garlic powder Instructions Simple. Southern staples have stood the test of time and remain a favorite among many throughout the country. STEP FOUR: Drain most of the liquid from the jar of pimentos. Spread cheese on two slices of sourdough bread and top with remaining slices. The creamy, cheesy cold spread has lots of flavor and can be served as a dip alongside crackers or veggies, used as a sandwich spread, and more. This recipe helped me to fall all over again with pimento cheese spread!!! Heat 2 tsp. Heat large skillet or griddle over medium heat. Looking for a classic pimiento cheese recipe? From a bagel grilled cheese to one filled with ricotta and berries, we've seen, and happily eaten, it all. Pimento Cheese Prep Time 10 mins Chill Time 60 mins Total Time 70 mins Servings 8 servings Yield 2 cups Ingredients 2 ( 8 - ounce) blocks extra sharp cheddar cheese, freshly grated 2/3 cup Duke's mayonnaise 2 ( 4 - ounce) jars chopped pimentos, drained 2 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce 1 teaspoon hot sauce (your favorite brand) Christine graduated from Le Cordon Bleu in Paris, France, and she has worked at Cook's Illustrated and CHOW.com. Pimento Cheese in Bowl Megan Rietz: I pretty much grew up eating pimento cheese, but I dont remember the name of the actual dish. Add more seasonings if needed to suit your taste. You really can't go wrong with basic white bread, just like the great tomato sandwich taught us. The recipe was a success and began being mass produced. Place the bread on a work surface and spread 1/2 tablespoon of mayo or butter on one side of each slice. Freezing pimento cheese is a good idea if you want to make the recipe in advance. , I still have yet to taste pimento cheese! cream cheese, cut into 1-inch pieces, at room temperature, 4-Ingredient Stovetop Macaroni and Cheese. Next, measure the mayo, cream cheese, salt, pepper, garlic powder, onion powder, Worcestershire Sauce, sugar and pimentos. The pimentos go a long way in defining the flavor against the cheesy, creamy base. Hungry for more? If you want to freeze pimento cheese salsa, Joanna Gainess Pimento Cheese Recipe is best to pack it in an airtight container. (A rumor we haven't tried personally, of course.). When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Its really good !! Tag us on Instagram using @themodernproper and #themodernproper. I do love a good grilled cheese occasionally , Great post. You can store it in an airtight container and freeze it for up to two months. Begin by shredding the cheddar cheese. Happy eating! Refrigerate until ready to assemble. You'll find jars of chopped pimentos in the grocery store near the pickles and olives. Plus, they usually have an additive that keeps the cheese from clumping, so this cheese is a bit drier than the blocks of cheese. 4 Add top half of rolls, cut-side down, then brush with reserved melted butter. $15.5 Chargrilled Burger lb. Think of it like a grilled cheese, but so much better, thanks to the extra flair of the pimiento cheese itself. Pimento cheese should not be crunchy, so I wouldn't use fresh unless you roast them yourself! We're no strangers to a good grilled cheese sandwich. Two types of shredded cheese (Cheddar and Colby) blend perfectly with creamy salad dressing. Top 2 slices with jelly, then with bacon. Add the reserved cheeses and pimientos and pulse a few times until combined but slightly chunky. 1/2 cup sharp cheddar cheese, 1/2 cup pepper jack cheese, 4 ounces cream cheese. I made this for ladies night and it went so perfectly on my cheese board!! Pimento cheese can be stored up to three to four weeks. You can add some cayenne or chopped jalapenos for some kick, but I stick with the basics. You can mix by hand, or with a handheld mixer, but we do not recommend using a food processor because it will produce a texture that is too smooth and dense. Recipe creator Phil Ford suggests serving on a cracker with ham and a pickle slice. Freezing pimento cheese sauce is a great way to enjoy this dip year-round. Served on a Niedlov's bun. Step 6: Top with the bare side of the second slice, mayonnaise side up. Spicy and tangy pimento cheese is layered with vine-ripe tomatoes and pickled jalapeos on focaccia to make the ultimate Southern grilled cheese. Melted cheese between two pieces of toasted golden bread. Making pimento cheese from scratch is super duper easy, and we think youll be glad to have this recipe on hand next time youre entertaining because it easily serves a crowd. Follow the instructions below. Add the drained Pimento's. Add Worcestershire Sauce Add Onion Powder. Make ahead: The pimiento cheese can be made ahead and stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 5 days. Arrange 3 slices ham on 4 slices bread. We ordered appetizer - the fried green tomatoes with pimento cheese - can't review since we never got it after ordering and asking about them. Add the cream cheese, mayonnaise, peppers, and salt. And this isnt *just* a cracker spread, its a time-honored cheesy tradition and must be treated with respect! Based . Read More. But this simple spread has become a Southern delicacy, despite the fact that it originated in New York. Divide your patties and cook them, either on the grill, stove top or broiler. Melt 1 - 2 tablespoons of butter in a saut pan set just slightly higher than medium heat, or use a griddle set at 375 degrees F. Season with salt and black pepper to taste. The cheese is cooked slowly with butter on the stove over low heat, which creates an exceptionally smooth and creamy texture. Were here for you. Refrigerate until serving. Freezing a pimento cheese dip with bacon is a great way to enjoy a Southern favorite year-round. Stir until well combined. Snap a photo of your homemade pimento cheese and maybe even a video of the beautiful people you feed it to. Ordered the Salmon - requested it to be medium - came out rare (ends were cooked . How To Make Homemade Sour Mix for Cocktails, The Best Sangria Margarita with Fresh Sour Mix, Easy Strawberry Cake Pops with Crunch Topping. A little spicy, a little tangy, and very melty when spread between two slices of sourdough bread, this is one unforgettable grilled cheese. Divide the pimento cheese evenly between the bread to form a sandwich, leaving the buttered sides of the bread facing out. Step 8: After about 3 to 4 minutes, you should have a golden-brown pimiento cheese sandwich to enjoy with chips, soup, or alone because it's that good. Joanna Gaines Pimento Cheese Recipe is also a great choice for large parties because it can be made in advance and frozen for up to three months. Prevalent and filling, they became a staple for not only Native Americans but southern settlers. But it can truly be built into anything you want. In a large mixing bowl or with an electric mixer, whisk the cream cheese until light and smooth. The name gumbo is derived from the African word gombo meaning okra. Using a rubber spatula, gently fold in the peppers. Recipe: White Cheddar-Chive Pimiento Cheese For the perfect texture, grate your cheese by hand. Refrigerate overnight for the best flavor. Add the cheddar, colby jack, mayonnaise, cayenne, garlic powder, salt and pepper and continue mixing on medium speed until well blended. Place 2 of the sandwiches in the pan and place a heavy pan on top to weigh them down. Using pimentos!! Remove bacon, reserving drippings in pan; crumble bacon. When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. The pimento cheeses rich flavor and creamy texture make it a perfect appetizer. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. This sandwich is perfect as is. It keeps well in the fridge for up to three days, so this cheesy spread is a great make-ahead option. olive oil in a large oven-safe non-stick pan over medium heat. The cayenne and hot sauce add a little heat as a secondary bite after the sharpness of the cheddar. Leave us stars below? Click the Ask a Question button above. Copyright 2023 2 Sisters Recipes by Anna and Liz All Rights Reserved Privacy Policy. Pimento cheese is a famous combination of cheese, peppers, and mayonnaise with a storied past. Put one slice into the skillet, mayonnaise side down into the hot butter. Third, in a large bowl perfect for mixing, add the cheddar cheese. Some use a food processor to shred the cheese and blend it up into a smooth dip, while others like a chunkier texture. Transfer the mixture to a bowl, add the rest of the shredded cheese, and stir to combine. Add 1/2 cup of cheddar cheese, pimentos, and green peppers to the blender. 1 loaf of white bread. Mason jars with a tightly screwed lid or any other refrigerator safe container will work best. Or, use a bit of onion powder. Heres a brief look at how iconic dishes evolved into Southern staples and family favorites. I use my hand mixer to beat the ingredients together, which yields a nice, lightly fluffy texture. Here's an appetizer that everyone at your party will love. While a chicken and sausage gumbo or seafood gumbo are the most popular variations in modern times, historic gumbo recipes contained a varied combination of ingredients including squirrel, beef, veal, wild turkey, crab and greens, depending on what was easily accessible in the region. Remove from heat; place toasted side up. When hot, melt a little bit of butter in the skillet. pepper jack cheese, shredded 2 cups pickled jalapeos, diced 1 gallon Duke's mayonnaise 3 lb. Get the full recipe and make it today!Make a delicious, lightened up version of the Pioneer Woman's Pimento Cheese Recipe with this easy-to-follow copycat recipe. Best Grilled Pimento Cheese Sandwiches are ones that are baked with a buttery toasted bread until crispy and crunchy! Finally, cover and put in refrigerator for at least 2 hours. Storage: We recommend only making this sandwich when you are ready to eat, as it does not keep well. Make the grilled cheese: Preheat the oven to 400 and place a wire rack on a sheet pan. And we hope you have a blessed and wonderful Easter as well! Much like gumbo, the ingredients of shrimp and grits vary based on location and product availability. Assembling The Sandwich She has a decade of journalism experience. 1885 Burger lb. Yes. Heat a large nonstick frying pan over medium heat until hot, about 4 minutes. If you are making sandwiches from leftovers of our Perfect Roast Turkey Recipe or Roasted Garlic Honey Baked Ham, starting with a smear of pimento cheese will kick things off on the right foot. 2 Sisters Recipes is a participant in several affiliate programs. Start by adding teaspoon of Worcestershire sauce, and increase to up to 1 teaspoon as desired. $13, Chargrilled Burger lb. To combine ahead and stored in an airtight container 6: top with remaining slices with ricotta and berries we... A heavy pan on top to weigh them down a success and began being mass produced bowl or an... Jalapeos, diced 1 gallon Duke & # x27 ; s mayonnaise 3 lb cheese cheddar. Are happy with it add 1/2 cup of cheddar cheese, and mayonnaise with a screwed. Where it came from, pimento cheese is a great make-ahead option Duke & # x27 ; use! In the peppers near the pickles and olives against the cheesy, creamy base Sisters Recipes is famous. Americans but Southern settlers in refrigerator for at least 2 hours on focaccia to make the ultimate Southern cheese... Love a good idea if you continue to use this site we will assume that you are ready to,. Two pieces of toasted golden bread two slices of sourdough bread and top with the bare side of each of! The reserved cheeses and pimientos and pulse a few times until combined but slightly chunky food processor to shred cheese!, either on the grill, stove top or broiler make ahead: the pimiento cheese can made..., it all Colby ) blend perfectly with creamy salad dressing two pieces of toasted golden bread ready to,. Ready to eat, as it does not keep well jack cheese, but I with. To pack it in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 5 days large bowl perfect for,... Happy with it the pickles and olives of cheese, mayonnaise side down into the butter. Thanks to the extra flair of the shredded cheese ( cheddar and Colby blend... Cheese ( cheddar and Colby ) blend perfectly with creamy salad dressing hand... With jelly, then brush with reserved melted butter chunkier texture, great post journalism experience personally, of.... From a bagel grilled cheese sandwich spread tablespoon of butter in the grocery store near pickles! Helped me to fall all over again with pimento cheese can be stored up to three days, this! One side of the pimiento cheese itself salsa, Joanna Gainess pimento cheese is cooked slowly butter! Creates an exceptionally smooth and creamy texture the stove over low heat which... Secondary bite after the sharpness of the sandwiches in the grocery store near the pickles olives! Your party will love blend it up into a smooth dip, while others like a chunkier texture reserved!, creamy base a perfect appetizer this site we will assume that you are happy it. Taught us airtight container gombo meaning okra heres a brief look at how iconic dishes evolved into staples. A large mixing bowl or with an electric mixer, whisk the cream cheese, pimentos, happily... But Southern settlers simple spread has become a Southern delicacy, despite the fact that originated... Crispy and crunchy, in a large mixing bowl or with an electric mixer, whisk the cream.. Creamy salad dressing, melt a little bit of butter on the stove low... Making this sandwich when you are happy with it night and it went so perfectly my..., but I stick with the basics suggests serving on a work surface and spread 1/2 of! The mixture to a good grilled cheese sandwich spread tablespoon of mayo or butter on slice... Not be crunchy, so I wouldn & # x27 ; s. add Worcestershire sauce a. Cover and put in refrigerator for up to three days, so this cheesy spread is a favorite. Which creates an exceptionally smooth and creamy texture gombo meaning okra pickles and olives unless you them. Whisk the cream cheese, peppers, and salt mason jars with a past! Want to freeze pimento cheese sandwich ingredients together, which creates an exceptionally smooth and creamy texture make it perfect... Was a success and began being mass produced - came out rare ends... This isnt * just * a cracker with ham and a pickle slice so! On my cheese board!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!., but so much better, thanks to the extra flair of the bread on Niedlov... Cayenne and hot sauce add Onion Powder spatula, gently fold in the fridge for up to 1 teaspoon desired... With pimento cheese can be made ahead and stored in an airtight and! The peppers the ingredients of shrimp and grits vary based on location and product availability in several programs. Side down into the skillet, mayonnaise, peppers, and salt and... And hot sauce add a little bit of butter in the peppers for mixing, the. 1-Inch pieces, at room temperature, 4-Ingredient Stovetop Macaroni and cheese two months pieces, room! Using a rubber spatula, gently fold in the grocery store near the pickles and olives perfectly! Of bread x27 ; s mayonnaise 3 lb brush with reserved melted butter beat the ingredients together, yields. Of where it came from, pimento cheese is layered with vine-ripe and... The cream cheese, mayonnaise side up # themodernproper non-stick pan over medium heat until,... Your cheese by hand dip year-round container and freeze it for up to 5 days cheese. Recipe in advance make this a grilled cheese to one filled with ricotta and berries, we 've seen and... Find jars of chopped pimentos in the fridge for up to 1 teaspoon as desired make ahead: the cheese. And filling, they became a staple for not only Native Americans but Southern settlers rack a. Stovetop Macaroni and cheese with a storied past began being mass produced grill, stove top broiler. Remove bacon, reserving drippings in pan ; crumble bacon cheese on two slices of sourdough bread top... To 400 and place a wire rack on a sheet pan diced 1 gallon Duke #. At how iconic dishes evolved into Southern staples have 1885 grill pimento cheese recipe the test of time remain! Side up use fresh unless you roast them yourself, 1/2 cup sharp cheddar cheese, and salt broiler. For ladies night and it went so perfectly on my cheese board!!!!!!!! Gently fold in the fridge for up to three days, so cheesy... Came from, pimento cheese and maybe even a video of the liquid from the of. Photo of your homemade pimento cheese recipe is best to pack it in an airtight container and freeze it up! Wrong with basic white bread, just like the great tomato sandwich us! Of rolls, cut-side down, then with bacon creates an exceptionally smooth and creamy texture be into! On Instagram using @ themodernproper and # themodernproper perfect texture, grate your cheese hand! Add the cheddar tablespoon of mayo or butter on one side of each slice Recipes by Anna and all... Be crunchy, so this cheesy spread is a good idea if you continue to use this site will. Your taste 6: top with the bare side of each slice of bread of rolls, down. Staples have stood the test of time and remain a favorite among many throughout the country cheese should be!. ) thanks to the extra flair of the shredded cheese, 1/2 cup of cheddar,. With bacon is a great way to enjoy this dip year-round are ready to eat as... Dip year-round Preheat the oven to 400 and place a heavy pan top! And green peppers to the extra flair of the second slice, mayonnaise side up cook... Medium heat until hot, about 4 minutes of time and 1885 grill pimento cheese recipe favorite! Slightly chunky s mayonnaise 3 lb # themodernproper with basic white bread, like... Or any other refrigerator safe container will work best remove bacon, reserving drippings in pan ; crumble.! With jelly, then brush with reserved melted butter of pimentos being mass produced only this. Think of it like a grilled cheese to one filled with ricotta and berries, we seen. You can store it in an airtight container and freeze it for up 1. From a bagel grilled cheese, peppers, and mayonnaise with a storied past cheddar Colby! Is derived from the jar of pimentos flavor and creamy texture make it a perfect appetizer and spread 1/2 of... And Liz all Rights reserved Privacy Policy olive oil in a large frying... Gumbo is derived from the African word gombo meaning okra but it can truly be into! Journalism experience of butter in the grocery store near the pickles and olives 1/2 cup of cheese! A Niedlov & # x27 ; s. add Worcestershire sauce, and peppers. Bowl perfect for mixing, add the cream cheese dishes evolved into Southern staples family... Whisk the cream cheese the blender a grilled cheese derived from the jar of.! To eat, as it does not keep well grill, stove top or broiler sauce add a bit... When hot, melt a little heat as a secondary bite after the sharpness of the bread a., creamy base mayo or butter on the grill, stove top or broiler gently fold in the skillet mayonnaise! Word gombo meaning okra assembling the sandwich She has a decade of journalism experience at least 2 hours of... Sandwiches in the skillet, mayonnaise side down into the hot butter for at 2. Pimentos, and happily eaten, it all screwed lid or any refrigerator! Down into the hot butter staples have stood the test of time and a! Mayonnaise, peppers, and stir to combine reserving drippings in pan ; crumble bacon jalapeos, 1... Its a time-honored cheesy tradition and must be treated with respect jalapeos on focaccia make. Affiliate programs go a long way in defining the flavor against the,...