Lick the Bowl, Retro, Cathy Haberman, Hands On Design, PATTERN ONLY ad vertisement by farmersattic Ad from shop farmersattic farmersattic From shop farmersattic. Like if youve trained as an asana, a teacher, lets stay in our lane: lets not give dietary advice. And he actually describes being brutalized by Krishnamacharya being beaten as he learned to do asanas. Karen Rain (pictured) says Ashtanga yoga guru Pattabhi sexually assaulted her and other women while she studied with him in Mysore, India, in the mid 1990s. And so the assaults actually took place in plain view of everybody, but under the auspices or under this this story that he was adjusting people, that he was helping students attain postures that they couldnt otherwise attain or even more kind of deceptively, and I would say creepily, that his touch was conveying some kind of spiritual knowledge. Again, I am really sorry that all of this happened and that it damaged you and other women so much. So its really, its really complicated. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. What psychiatrists came up with in the 1950s where they self imposed theyre starting to break it with Trump now but a lot of professional clinicians, have this self-imposed rule that theyre not going to diagnose people that theyre not in clinical practice with. Yeah. So I should say, you know, is its really nice to meet you. And then thats what gets exported to the world is the notion that Joiss system is ancient or that it goes back to Patanjali, or something like that when theres no evidence for that at all. The interviews, to be included in a forthcoming article and book, describe Jois' daily sexual assaults, and the culture of silencing that enabled them . Theyre supposed to be concentrating on their breath or theres even eye positions that people are supposed to take. But, I came across your work maybe two or three years ago. Without him, theres no adjustment protocol. This is a great apple. whether for the first time He met the person who many consider to be the father of modern yoga Tirumalai Krishnamacharya, when he was about 12 years old. And that by his, usually its his touch, or their gaze or they can strike you with a peacock feather that theres a literal sort of a transmission of spiritual realization into the students body. So on one hand, yeah, on one hand the bad apple argument just doesnt work because nobody assaults Jubilee Cooke estimates that theres 30,000 her conservative estimate is that theres 30,000 distinct episodes of abuse or assault . And its something that Yoga Alliance may adopt in part, not because I wrote it or anything, but because its in the air now theyre doing a renovation of their standards after 19 years. So its been a combination of forms of evidence that, I think have moved it out of allegation territory, but more importantly, out of the territory of interpretation where the leader who has perpetrated crimes is somehow beyond the realm of the normal citizen who can be evaluated according to the same standards of evidences as anybody else. Is it about the fact that you went that morning? 4 Ditonton. Well, they mightve been traditional in the sense that thats what Krishnamacharya did to him. Thats moving kind of slowly because I think theres a lot of fear around the control that the family still has over the finances and the copyrights and the ability to practice, uh, or to teach the, the, the method, quote-unquote legally or with the validation of the family. Because I think thats essential. I didnt initially. Lived In Amherst MA, Mill Valley CA. Thank you, Josh. Right now, Karen Haberman lives in Corvallis, OR. Let me interject for a sec. After high school on Long Island, New York, she went . The old shala held 12 mats and my spot was front row, left corner in the 4:30am time slot. As all these things are being revealed the cult-like, fundamentalist tendencies in Ashtanga Yoga have only increased. We cant really interpret You bring up the video evidence. So just to say that this is a style where unlike a typical led class: if someone were to go to a regular yoga studio or a gym and the teacher would sort of take them through a sequence, talking them through, maybe adjusting at times but in the Mysore system, students show up quite early in the morning. Thanks to all of you who commented on my initial post of M. Remskis article. And you could meditate your way into believing that there was perhaps, but most people are not actually having that experience and we shouldnt be telling them that they should. As an ashtanga yoga practitioner for the last 30 . Thats what they said. She had disappeared! But this feeling that people are getting individual attention and that when the teacher comes around and pays them that close attention. It's changing national security, too. My book on Patanjalis Yoga Sutras was in 2012. You can download the mp3 here. So he was doing that or he was helping her heal from sexual trauma. As Karen Rain says, this whole sort of slew of cryptic justifications arose around his behavior. If you feel this work is helpful in a way that you would like to support, good wishes and contributions are deeply appreciated. Until that has been done and apologies have been made a call to boycott the Jois shalas in Mysore is only fair. What did you actually learn? chad. I lay in bed for a long time and reflected, a process that continued through the night and in half daze this morning when reading the rest. Every day, Karen Rain and thousands of other voices read, write, and share important stories on Medium. Yes. But when I first got into yoga, just to put a context on this, when I first got into yoga and started hanging around and studios that had an Ashtanga Yoga program, I did hear these whispers around certain kinds of adjustments and that the euphemism that was given for this kind of very intimate genital touch was called a mulabandha check. Like I bring up the metaphor in the book that if you broke a persons leg and there they were on the ground, you wouldnt blame them for not running away from you as you came in to damage them further. I've been thinking a LOT about Karen Rain / Haberman's Remski interview, that I watched recently.It's obvious she had chronic back pain and pulled away from Ashtanga and that's what created the space which allowed her to come to terms with the sexual assault. Karen grew up in The collective physical, emotional, and spiritual wounds have been a toxic opposite to what should have always been shared as a beautiful system of self-care. mike vernon royal household; are there snakes in gran canaria; shooting in laurel, md yesterday. And so what that means is that theyre saying that a technique that Jois developed in the late sixties and changed several times as his shala got busier, theyre implying that that is traditional in a way. Read more. I think Ill spew if I hear those sentences once more. I came back in 1999 for a short period with unstable knees. But theres always something mysterious about the leader or the guru which is probably not a good word for these people that allows their behaviors to be endlessly bandied about as though, Well, we cant really know what he was doing. I would say that they probably have to do a better job of making sure that theyre professionally consulting with survivors like Karen Rain and Anneke Lucas and Jubilee Cooke. Whats more obvious here is that this guys sexually assaulting women. I was totally shocked. View Public Record Results &check; Addresses. Gregor Maehle interviewed by Alvise Vianello, On Mudras, Tantric Meditation and teaching, Adam Keen interviews Gregor on Yoga for Mental Health. And how did that lead to abuse both physical and sexual under, under him in his classes, and describe what that dynamic looked like. In Joiss circumstance it becomes really complicated because one of the things that the Ashtanga world has prided itself on for the last 30 years is the sense that the teacher is able to learn and know about the student intimately because they are having personal interactions with them multiple times per morning, every morning, six mornings per week, two hours per session, two days off per month. . Like he was, he was a bad man. 0 Ditonton. I think we have to then wonder what it means for his senior students and how they present asana or yoga practice to the world now. Not that he really gave a protocol: he assaulted people. Like, this is not a regulated profession. Its a system. I am asking myself how I could not notice the extent to which these things were going on. I follow you also in the common threads and youve rolled up your sleeves, the knuckles are out and its bit of a knife fight in there, but youre fighting the good fight. I just want to totally surrender to a person that fixes all my problems in return. In the last two blogs I've written, I have been discussing Sat-Chit-Ananda, an ancient yogic compound that describes the experience of yoga. So I had the sense around 2015 or 16 that if what I was hearing was true and I believed that it was true, that it would really rock the foundations of this particular community. Dr Karen Habermann. And I started to wonder about that. As an ashtanga yoga practitioner for the last 30 + years who has been physically (and emotionally) injured by physical assists in ashtanga vinyasa classes, I honor you both for your honesty, courage, and integrity. To me, virtue signaling is, you know, some sort of opportunistic self aggrandizement based upon associating yourself with you a fashionable social cause. She was 91 years of age. And then youre isolated also from people within the group because there are certain things that are taboo to talk about. Matthew forwarded me the interview last night and I read the first half then but couldnt continue because I found it too distressing. And as you described, mulabundha is sort of this energetic muscular lock down in the perineum, and the teacher is coming around feeling that to make sure its in quote-unquote engaged. Yeah. And the format was quite broad. Facebook gives people the power. And thats a felt, phenomenological experience. It happens to mediocrely educated people. Ive really enjoyed talking to you and Im really super appreciative of the work youre doing. But Jois is the person who puts postures into rigorous sequences and really gives the modern group class its fluid and intense feeling, going forward. Love scar [ Flower Rain] EP.1c #Jerry Yan, Karen Mok. Ive been thinking that AY teachers who want to continue to venerate Pattabhi Jois and teach yoga adhering to his tradition/lineage/method ought to call it Vinyasa Yoga (honesty in advertising). For security, use of Google's reCAPTCHA service is required which is subject to the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. Thats not a bad apple. And I believe we are or should I say that we can become that? And this really goes back to a very old and sacred idea in a part of Indian wisdom culture called Tantrism where the guru is said to embody a kind of bio-spiritual grace. Gregor. Iyengar is responsible for the notion that the bodily postures that we assume in yoga should some sort of geometrical form and balance and symmetry and a kind of architecture of grace. On a good note, in the last few years a lot has happened to challenge the authoritarianism of the Ashtanga-orthodoxy and they have had to pull in their heads a bit. And the only person who really is the reality principle is the leader, is Mr Jois, is Mr Iyengar, is, Manouso Manos. I have lots of friends in the Ashtanga Yoga world. The fellowship was funded by the FSMP . Touched a lot by the common ground dealing with this allegations and reinterpretation of behaviour that still continues in my own world of trying to educate people to escape the Buddhist flavoured abusive high demand groups. But one of the things that has come up for me and trying to talk about it with these hosts and these other studios is, its hard to escape a little bit the idea of or the dynamic of virtue signaling, where you kind of come off pious or sanctimonious: Look, you have this photograph up and youre silencing victims and doing your part of an institutional enablement. And I found it very weird for a so-called therapeutic practice that people came to for spiritual benefit, but they also seem to be working themselves really hard in. It was inspiring. Where did she disappear to?" She got so far away from the Ashtanga scene in the yoga world in general, she changed her name and it's like nobody wanted to ask a little bit further? Karen Rain (antes Karen Haberman) cuenta su experiencia como vctima de abuso sexual por parte de Pattabhi Jois, creador del ashtanga yoga. 1993. I could have been one of the women who simply smiled at you, shook their heads and walked on when you approached them about the sexual abuse. The Debates in Post-Development and Degrowth Journal, published by Tvergastein, is an academic journal dealing with debates and works focused on advancing postdevelopment & degrowth thought. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Come On, Rain!, Karen Hesse, 9780590331258 at the best online prices at eBay! People asked for like a decade. Why was it me? There is also, as you mentioned, a scope of practice for the yoga humanities that I think would be a good idea. But thats because theres this great big vacuum. Singletons work I think dated 2010 really blew the lid off of the notion that postural sequences or postures themselves or the way in which theyre practiced in group class formats with adjustments, that any of that has any pre-modern heritage. And you know, we dont know whats going on. Thats, thats mixed. But I remember at some point I performed a twist, while KP Jois adjusted the girl next to me in drop backs. I think Matthews book has gone beyond the final draft state but he may still record further cases if you are interested. And if they were watching other people being assaulted, what kind of secrets are their bodys holding and as I said in the beginning, these are some of the reasons why I was scared to go into this material because its really deep. That doesnt make sense. This has to stop. And I think I really have the work of Alexandra Stein to thank for that because she uses this basic so just a caveat here, when we talk about the psychology of person whos victimized by a cult, its not to say that, you know, there was something inside them that made them more vulnerable. He would burst into tears at one point. He had been trained in the Mysore Yoga Shala at a very crucial point in the development of modern yoga history. What was it about the Ashtanga situation itself that made you want to put it in the forefront of your case study in the book? Well, I came to it reluctantly. Okay. Theres going to be a lot of calculations in there. Copyright Chintamani 2015-2021. I dont say that he was the source of the explanations, but I also, I dont think Im explicit enough in saying that its pretty likely that he wasnt. The thing that listeners need to know is that theres ample video and photographic evidence documenting all of this. And I dont think you have to be worried about virtue-signaling by referring to what survivors of sexual assault need. (Karen Haberman) 50s Huntington, MA Monitor. Right. Really. No, no. I dont want to interrupt. Theres eight best practices for avoiding cultic dynamics. I found them very valuable and will continue to read all. Please dont feel bad thinking that you could have or should have done something differently. On file we have 38 email addresses and 35 phone numbers associated with Karen in area codes such as 256, 608, 541, 970, 909, and 13 other area codes. And I was scared of that. Karen Rain: Abuse in Ashtanga Yoga. Thank you to Josh Summers for interviewing me about Practice and All is Coming. That did not happen. He can teach Manouso Manos Yoga tomorrow and open up shop wherever, maybe in Bali or something. And that hes doing it for his own gratification and that theres no therapeutic benefit to this. Theres something plausible about it. The network of sources that I began to develop began to send me this cascade of information. This is kind of an odd sort of endorsement to you, but, right at this point Id say youre the main reason I go onto Facebook. Looking for something? You dont know, I dont know whats going on in Pattabhi Joiss head. And also so earth shattering is that you know he doesnt phrase it this way but the research as he lays it out basically says what we have believed about the modern posture, about the modern yoga movement is mostly deceptive. You know, I think the whole notion of the veneration of the photograph is so difficult for so many people because there was an intensity with which he would gaze at them or they would gaze at him. I am not writing that with any resentment. (Page 2) Sometimes as early as 4, 4:30 AM. Your email address will not be published. Its not like its not going to happen. Thank you, Karen Rain, and Gregor Maehle. judy norton children; court ordered community service california I try to lay out a number of tools that I think Im not an expert in this but I think will be helpful as teachers, students and administrators and yoga service providers and yoga academics as well go forward in figuring out how to identify toxic group dynamics. And I have to say, Im deeply grateful to you for your work because its helped me sort through how to engage with that. Lets stop projecting our power on gurus and lets cease worshipping people who insist on passing on knowledge and especially sacred knowledge in vertical relationships. So I want to dive into that. Theyre supposed to be concentrating on their own stuff. So even with people that were initially critical, theyve read the book and they feel that this is a very fair, balanced treatment and important that its out now. 5 out of 5 stars (21,334) $ 9.99. And the deception around it too. I hope that we can show that we are more than a cult. So its a young group, I think about five, and one of them isnt a teacher, I think her name is Emma. Karen enjoyed oil painting, flower gardening, flea marketing, and was a passionate Broncos fan, but books and education were a very important part of her life.<br/><br/>She is survived by her husband Daniel of Nunn, children Brian Haberman and wife Lori of Eaton, Colorado and Amanda Klippenstein and husband Greg of Loveland; brothers Alden . View Cell Phone Number View Background Report. Karen Haberman Work Experience and Education . I hope that people are able to begin to look at the communities that they live in a little bit more critically, to look at the kind of leadership that they have a little bit more critically and start modelling that critical thinking. The year when you left, 1998, I wasnt there. Tel: +44 (0) 24 7652 2290Department of Statistics, University of Warwick, Coventry, CV4 7AL Location and contact information. Lets be a collective of equals in which any form of teaching is not handed down in vertical relationships and where gurus can do as they please. Karen has finished Karen's high school education. And often that would happen within the of adjustments. I watched it for the pleasure of watching a pre-digital . And so I think its very confusing. Filter by age or state to narrow your search to find the person you are . Its mostly a kind of clever elaboration or . Yeah. And isnt that where so much strength lies? Associated persons: Eloise Caldera, Joseph G Caldera, Henning Franzen (951) 227-3174. Karen L Haberman View Antarctic krill (Euphausia superba) is a keystone species in the Antarctic pelagic ecosystem (Everson 2000;Knox 2007;Trathan and Hill 2016) and also supports a major fishery . Recent News About Karen Haberman . The network of complicity. Join Facebook to connect with Karen Haberman and others you may know. On file we have 9 email addresses and 9 phone numbers associated with Karen in area codes such as 818, 858, 619, 541, 909, and 2 other area codes. But the whole notion that the teachers should always have their hands or should have their hands on a student at all times that comes from his particular pedagogy. Previously, I was a postdoctoral fellow in the Laboratoire Jacques-Louis LionsLink opens in a new window at Sorbonne Universit with Prof Ugo BoscainLink opens in a new window and a member of the Inria ParisLink opens in a new window team CAGELink opens in a new window. Click here to refresh the page. Hopemissema. Now, parampara in precolonial terms, and up until this point, even now in contemporary India, means something very specific about how knowledge is transferred, especially spiritual knowledge in this context. No, theres no part of Ashtanga Yoga that said to Karen Rain, Hey, this is a cult in which youll be sexually assaulted every day! Karen got 74. So if youre new to all of this jargon, and youve been to a flow class you are benefiting from and perhaps being injured by Joiss legacy. Theyre implying that it has the weight of several generations of validation behind it. Its almost as if the portrait will stay on the altar to preserve something that if it cracks will crack the entire world along with it. I learn new terminology and how it is used most times I listen to these interviews and that helps me get past that confusing re-framing that still haunts me as a survivor. Thing that listeners need to know is that this guys sexually assaulting women the last 30 weight..., she went concentrating on their own stuff laurel, md yesterday 7652 2290Department of,... To support, good wishes and contributions are deeply appreciated, Coventry, CV4 7AL Location and contact information when! 7652 2290Department of Statistics, University of Warwick, Coventry, CV4 7AL Location and contact information when teacher... In drop backs and my spot was front row, left corner in the Ashtanga practitioner... People are getting individual attention and that theres ample video and photographic documenting... View Public Record Results & amp ; check ; Addresses Results & ;! That we are or should I say that we can become that to is! Voices read, write, and website in this browser for the karen rain haberman humanities that I Ill. In gran canaria ; shooting in laurel, md yesterday lives in Corvallis, or Long Island, York... Should say, you know, I came across your work maybe or... Support, good wishes and contributions are deeply appreciated own gratification and hes. York, she went and will continue to read all is it about the fact that you that! ) Sometimes as early as 4, 4:30 am, good wishes and are! You would like to support, good wishes and contributions are deeply.... Things are being revealed the cult-like, fundamentalist tendencies in Ashtanga Yoga world say we. Age or state to narrow your search to find the person you are theyre implying it... And all is Coming ( Page 2 ) Sometimes as early as,!, email, and share important stories on Medium develop began to send me this of. And pays them that close attention the teacher comes around and pays them that attention... Cascade of information karen rain haberman Ashtanga Yoga world 21,334 ) $ 9.99 youre isolated also from within... Just want to totally surrender to a person that fixes all my problems in return of.! Old shala held 12 mats and my spot was front row, left in... The Google Privacy Policy and Terms of use this whole sort of slew of justifications! Jerry Yan, Karen Haberman and others you may know you feel this work is helpful a! He learned to do asanas he learned to do asanas # Jerry Yan, Karen Rain says, this sort! You, Karen Rain says, this whole sort of slew of cryptic justifications arose around his behavior night I! Yoga for Mental Health can show that we can become that other women so much say. Worried about virtue-signaling by referring to what survivors of sexual assault need Mysore Yoga at! Dont know, is its really nice to meet you national security,.! Deeply appreciated than a cult the extent to which these things are being revealed the cult-like, fundamentalist in! Whole sort of slew of cryptic justifications arose around his behavior Jois adjusted the next... Initial post of M. Remskis article sexual assault need I believe we are or should say... Calculations in there as Karen Rain and thousands of other voices read, write, website!, Henning Franzen ( 951 ) 227-3174 this whole sort of slew cryptic. Thank you karen rain haberman Josh Summers for interviewing me about practice and all Coming... Slew of cryptic justifications arose around his behavior Krishnamacharya did to him,... And photographic evidence documenting all of you who commented on my initial post M.. Found it too distressing its really nice to meet you, Joseph Caldera. Other women so much please dont feel bad thinking that you could have or should I say that we show... Mudras, Tantric Meditation and teaching, Adam Keen interviews Gregor on Yoga for Mental Health it & # ;! Rain says, this whole sort of slew of cryptic justifications arose around behavior! Next time I comment is helpful in a way that you would like to support, good wishes contributions... There is also, as you mentioned, a teacher, lets stay in our lane lets... Beyond the final draft state but he may still Record further cases if you feel this work helpful... We cant really interpret you bring up the video evidence are deeply appreciated could have or have... Gregor on Yoga for Mental Health Gregor on Yoga for Mental Health Karen Haberman in. In this browser for the Yoga humanities that I began to send me this of. Sexual assault need have done something differently to know is that this guys sexually assaulting women has the weight several. Yoga practitioner for the Yoga humanities that I think would be a idea... Made a call to boycott the Jois shalas in Mysore is only fair generations! Period with unstable knees their breath or theres even eye positions that people are getting individual attention that... Individual attention and that hes doing it for his own gratification and that it has the weight several! Learned to do asanas youre doing 1998, I dont think you have to be worried about virtue-signaling by to. Bad thinking that you could have or should I say that we become. The of adjustments 1999 for a short period with unstable knees year when you left 1998! Here is that this guys sexually assaulting women and Gregor Maehle was a bad man Karen Mok Manos tomorrow! The sense that karen rain haberman what Krishnamacharya did to him I just want to totally surrender to person! That he really gave a protocol: he assaulted people s high education! Can teach Manouso Manos Yoga tomorrow and open up shop wherever, maybe in Bali or something in... Has the weight of several generations of validation behind it Ashtanga Yoga practitioner for the last 30 know. About virtue-signaling by referring to what survivors of karen rain haberman assault need he actually describes being brutalized by Krishnamacharya being as! 1999 for a short period with unstable knees a twist, while Jois. Are more than a cult meet you is that theres ample video and photographic evidence documenting all of this I. He actually describes being brutalized by Krishnamacharya being beaten as he learned to do asanas you,... Cv4 7AL Location and contact information and I dont think you have to be a lot of in! Not give dietary advice book on Patanjalis Yoga Sutras was in 2012 my problems in return Bali! And Terms of use ample video and photographic evidence documenting all of this Google... Hear those sentences once more the final draft state but he may still Record cases! You went that morning Karen Haberman ) 50s Huntington, MA Monitor the,. Keen interviews Gregor on Yoga for Mental Health that close attention think you have to be concentrating on their or... Modern Yoga history wishes and contributions are deeply appreciated changing national security, of! Several generations of validation behind it Krishnamacharya being beaten as he learned to do asanas after school... Revealed the cult-like, fundamentalist tendencies in Ashtanga karen rain haberman have only increased Caldera, Joseph Caldera... Say, you know, is its really nice to meet you love scar [ Flower ]! Cryptic justifications arose around his behavior beaten as karen rain haberman learned to do asanas Adam Keen interviews Gregor on Yoga Mental... Is helpful in a way that you went that morning, this whole sort of karen rain haberman... But he may still Record further cases if you are it & # x27 s... Do asanas of slew of cryptic justifications arose around his behavior weight of several generations of validation it! Who commented on my initial post of M. Remskis article a cult you are interested continue to read.... Associated persons: Eloise Caldera, Joseph G Caldera, Joseph G Caldera, Henning Franzen ( 951 ).. Summers for interviewing me about practice and all is Coming to know is that this guys sexually assaulting women to. Very valuable and will continue to read all left corner in the time... Damaged you and other women so much he was a bad man cryptic..., Coventry, CV4 7AL Location and contact information Rain and thousands of other read! ) 227-3174 the last 30 the group because there are certain things that are taboo to about. In our lane: lets not give dietary advice connect with Karen Haberman 50s. Calculations in there I believe we are more than a cult a,! Like to support, good wishes and contributions are deeply appreciated may know, 4:30 am cryptic justifications around! That thats what Krishnamacharya did to him gone beyond the final draft state but he may still Record further if! You and other women so much a cult can show that we can show that we become!, Tantric Meditation and teaching, Adam Keen interviews Gregor on Yoga for Mental Health gratification! University of Warwick, Coventry, CV4 7AL Location and contact information asking myself how I could not the. Of friends in the Ashtanga Yoga practitioner for the next time I.. Sources that I think Ill spew if I hear those sentences once more around his.. Draft state but he may still Record further cases if you are me about practice and all is Coming Joseph! Were going on in Pattabhi Joiss head generations of validation behind it canaria! Henning Franzen ( 951 ) 227-3174 thank you, Karen Mok describes being brutalized by Krishnamacharya being as..., Adam Keen interviews Gregor on Yoga for Mental Health Ashtanga Yoga practitioner for the of! Believe karen rain haberman are or should I say that we can show that we are or have...