Look for a lively one, as you would with a Maine lobster, and never buy a dead lobster that has not been frozen, as enzymes in the lobster can rot the meat very quickly. Spiny lobsters have the capability to grow up to 20 pounds but are usually harvested when they . Would you like to receive our daily news in your inbox? They can grow to about 60 cm or 2 feet in length and weigh about 15 pounds. Season: Aug. 6-March 31 Daily Bag Limit: 6 per person Possession limit on the water: Equal to the daily bag limit Minimum Size Limit: Carapace must be larger than 3", measured in the water. Also called Rock lobster, the Spiny lobster also has an antenna much longer than its Maine counterpart. There is a Lobster season and legal length and method requirements that vary from country to country and even state to state within the same country. Crawfish are also known as 'crayfish.'. As a result of their soft meat and weight, they are considered the heaviest crustaceans globally. They are also called the "rock lobster," or "spiny lobster" and can be found mostly on the California coastline and the Caribbean. Rock lobsters Rock lobsters or spiny lobsters are known for their long antennas, which have been reported to sometimes be longer than their bodies. - Maine lobsters live in the cold waters of the Atlantic Ocean. However, like spiny lobsters, they live in muddy caves, rock reefs, crevices, or burrows on the sea floors worldwide. The colder water keeps the Maine Lobsters from tasting too "fishy". Anomurans are superficially crab-like. The upside, according to Mainer, is that Spiny lobster tails actually have more meat than Maine ones. Lobster use their antennae to track down food that is further away from their homes. The difference in taste between the spiny lobster and the Maine lobster is significant. If you are the site owner (or you manage this site), please whitelist your IP or if you think this block is an error please open a support ticket and make sure to include the block details (displayed in the box below), so we can assist you in troubleshooting the issue. Spiny Lobster and Maine Lobster - Why are they different? The important thing is that they have differences in the taste of lobster meat. In January, Chinese buyers should have been paying top dollar for large amounts of spiny lobster from the Keys and South Florida in preparation for the Chinese New Year on Jan. 22. The reason is that there is very little edible meat outside of the tails since they lack the large claws that Maine lobsters have. Spiny lobsters have very little meat and are smaller than Northern lobsters. 95% of them are shipped to China, as that market fetches up to 3X more than local customers. Small lobsters are too "short" to take legally. Please call the FWC Marathon office at 305-289-2320. What Size Insulated Fish Bag Should I Buy? You may find Maine lobsters sold under these common nicknames: True lobsters are sought after for their unrivaled flavor. Its all a matter of choice, so try both types, and see which one you prefer! The Maine Lobster, with shells that appear quite red after cooking, is the namesake of the restaurant chain for a reason. Spiny lobster Votes: 40 75.5% Maine lobster Votes: 13 24.5% Total voters 53 1 2 Next Tifoso CA Halibut,DoDos,YT,Albies,Rockfish,Lings,Crappie Jul 25, 2016 1,003 491 norCal (central valley) www.bdoutdoors.com Name Lou Boat Name Let LobsterBox show you some useful information about lobsters! King's Seafood Co.mentions that Spiny lobsters are also harvested off the shores of California from October through March. Thats rightspiny lobsters dont have claws! This article will uncover all you need to know about both species of lobster, including their diets, preferred habitats, tastes, and behaviors. It doesnt have the large claws for hunting and defense like its cousin from the state of Maine. The first thing you should know is that there is a significant difference between the two. Of which sugar: 0g. 2. the fins of as many as 73 million sharks are taken by fishermen, US companies accused of illegal involvement in lucrative shark-fin trade, Florida lobstermen hoping for "normal season with good pricing", Pandemic accelerates major shifts in Chinas seafood marketplace, Florida lobster fishermen hope for normal season, DSAR Requests / Do Not Sell My Personal Info. Usually, Maine lobsters are considered tastier than spiny lobsters because of their colder habitat. Lobster are nocturnal. This meat is usually thicker and firmer than the meat found in lobsters' claws. You can cook rock lobster similarly to Atlantic lobster, such as by grilling or steaming. Ty - the reason is supply and demand more than taste. And these days, you don't need to live on the brisk Maine coast to access a lobster dinner. Maine lobsters have 10 spindly legs (which have a small amount of meat in them), and a long, thick tail. As you can see, the antenna is very large and thick, plus theres no large claw either. | Contact Us. These tasty crustaceans are found as far north as Labrador in Canada and as far south as North Carolina. Maine Lobster is said to taste better due to the colder habitat in which it lives. Most American lobsters are sold between 1 and 2 pounds and roughly 9 inches long. First of all, the lack of claws is a good indication that youre looking at a rock lobster, not a Maine lobster. All rights reserved. Generally, lobster employs a very different and unique flavor. American lobsters are in the Astacidea infraorder, while spiny lobsters are in the Palinura infraorder. Seems pretty straight forward right? To view our latest special e-Edition click the image on the left. Rock Lobster vs Maine Lobster: Key Differences and Why They Matter, The Best, Lobsterman-Approved Ways to Cook Maine Lobster, Showdown: Why Maine Lobster is the Best Lobster, The Easiest Way to Get Your Hands on Maine Lobster, Diagnosing Cheap Lobster: Mushy Meat, Discoloration, Fake Lobster, and More, The best ways to find and prepare Maine vs Rock Lobsters, Or even sea crayfish because of their similar shape to spiny crayfish, Maine lobsters carry more meat in their robust claws (which spiny lobsters are missing altogether), Atlantic lobsters also have a naturally sweeter flavor that needs little to no seasoning to shine on the plate, Theyre easier to cook and handle, thanks to the smooth, spike-free body, Their texture is succulent and meaty, never dry, 100% real lobster with no added preservatives. Prices of fresh lobster have surged ever since. A small female Lobster can have as many as 6,000 eggs while a large female can carry as many as 100,000 eggs! Spiny lobsters ( Palinuridae) are a family of crustaceans with about 60 species. Even though they lack pincers, i.e., they do not have claws, they have a longer and spiny antenna relative to Maine lobsters. Because they are somewhat alike, knowing where they can be found is an important factor in telling them apart. This is why the Rock lobsters at Red Lobster only come in tails. In short, there is no taste difference. Find out how to measure a spiny lobster.. Report injured, orphaned or dead manatees, Florida Youth Conservation Centers Network, Coral Reef Protection Areas in Biscayne National Park, Regulations for Recreational Harvest and Lobster Information for Monroe County, saltwater fishing license and a lobster permit, See a full list of our Social Media accounts, No person shall harvest or attempt to harvest spiny lobster using any device which will or could puncture, penetrate or crush the exoskeleton (shell) or the flesh of the lobster. Choosing the Right Lobster Types For more information, please see our Disclaimerbelow. Rock lobsters are noticeably less sweet than Maine lobsters. As you might guess, Maine lobsters are found in Maine. When divers grab these lobster they wear special Kevlar gloves to keep from getting poked by these spines. Lobster in the wild. Another difference between Maine Lobster and Spiny Lobster is the size of their antennae. An email message containing instructions on how to reset your password has been sent to the e-mail address listed on your account. Yes, lobster is a delicious, meaty seafood variety that can be enjoyed in dozens of tasty ways, from hot buttered rolls to creamy mac and cheese and much more. Many of you wonder how long a lobster will live out of the water. The season was off to a rough start with Hurricane Ian destroying thousands of traps between Key West and the Dry Tortugas. They have four trucks going up and down the road at any given time, Nichols said after company officials were indicted last June. Canadian Lobster like Boston/Maine Lobster are nice and juicy. Assistant U.S. Attorney Thomas Watts-FitzGerald prosecuted the case. Around the time that European settlers arrived in North America, lobsters were so plentiful that they would wash up on the eastern shores in piles. As you can see in the picture above, the Spiny Lobster does not have any claws. Like spiny lobsters, the American lobster can detach and discard a leg or claw through a process known as autotonomy. MARATHON A federal judge in Key West has sentenced the operators of Elite Sky International Inc., a company based in Marathon, to a quarter-million dollar fine and five years of probation for exporting falsely labeled spiny lobster and shark fins from Florida to China. Maine lobsters are typically between 8 and 24 inches in length and may have a mass of over 20.1 kg (44lbs). The largest one on record had a10-inch carapace length and weighed more than 21 pounds. Langostinos are in the Anomura infraorder, with and hermit and porcelain crabs, and in the Galatheidae family. As you might imagine, these spikes make holding and preparing the lobsters (live or dead) not so fun for home cooks. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Farris Bryant Building Expert lobstermen and chefs agree. On 23 February, a federal judge sentenced Marathon, Florida, U.S.A.-based seafood wholesaler, distributor, and exporter Elite Sky International for falsely labeling approximately 63,000 pounds of lobster imported from Nicaragua and Belize as U.S.-caught live Florida spiny lobster. The meat is much sweeter that . In fact, spiny lobsters are the largest food export of the Bahamas. In addition, spiny lobsters earn their name because of the hard spikes running the length of their tail and bodies. Some refer to them as American lobster or Northern lobster, but as expected by their most common name, they are plentiful in the northeastern coastal waters, from Canada to North Carolina, with their numbers drastically dwindling the further south they go. Most of the hotels in The Keys book up early, but there are other alternatives. There are at least 50,000 to 70,000 traps between Smith Shoal and the Dry Tortugas, said Bill Kelly, executive director of the Florida Keys Commercial Fishermens Association. Each type has many different sizes so the price is also different accordingly. They have four trucks going up and down the road at any given time, Nichols said. To people who enjoy shellfish, the two taste very similar, but you can only order one of them whole. If the tank is full of dark reddish-brown shellfish with a smooth body and prominent claws, youre looking at true lobsters (yet another name for Maine lobsters). People took a liking to the sweet meat and suddenly, these "cockroaches of the sea," as they were called, became a gourmet item, one that people would travel to New England to eat. These true lobsters are the most sought-after crustaceans on the market for a reason: Are you sold yet? Submitting this form below will send a message to your email with a link to change your password. They are faster than you think. With one flip of the tail, these critters can take off in the blink of an eye, leaving a diver bewildered and empty-handed. And Heierling would know. You will often see these antennae sticking out of the rocks well before you can see any other part of the Lobster. The lobsters found in the Pacific are rock or spiny lobsters, not "true" lobsters like the ones found in Maine or Canada. During the daylight hours you will find lobster hiding in structure. November 29, 2022 Huy Le There are many types of lobsters. Usually in holes in rocks and reefs. Theyre found around the world, including the Caribbean, Southeast Asia, and Australia. Where To Get The Best Caribbean Lobster Meals There are a few more differences that will be good for anyone looking for either species of lobster to know. The spiny lobster has a hard shell, longer antennae, and longer, spidery-looking legs compared to the Maine lobster. Florida spiny lobster is important for the entire Sunshine State. Marine biologists have tracked lobsters equipped with sonar tags for weeks at a time. They can both be used in a number of ways to make a perfect dish. In the United States, most rock lobster comes from Florida and southern California. Nichols, who has been selling spiny lobster to the company for 12 years, said the it has a holding tank at its Marathon operation that can house 350,000 pounds of live lobster. Rock Lobsters also have a more muted flavor compared to the Atlantic Lobster and require more seasoning to get a good dish. From November 2018 through October . VisitMaine or have live Maine lobsters shipped to you. You have permission to edit this article. But what are the key differences between the spiny lobster and the Maine lobster? Spiny lobsters don't. The two are not closely related, being the same order as crabs, shrimp and crayfish. Coarse salt, to taste. Check out our article for the best lobster diving gear and equipment. 2 teaspoons chopped fresh cilantro. Copyright text 2018 by Sportfishing Lures. Call us at 978.225.8828. Maine lobsters can escape backward from predators by flapping their tails for a quick burst of speed. Access from your Country was disabled by the administrator. Lobsters are great travelers and they tend to move around more at night. The cook prepared one and a half lobster tails per person. Available year-round, with their numbers spiking in late summer and into fall, Maine lobsters are considered the ultimate lobster delicacy, per The University of Maine. The Spiny lobster lacks one notable feature: The giant claws. Cut lobster tail into 4 pieces with shell intact. But dont assume a lobster hunting out on the open sand is easy pickings. Enter your email in the box below to get the most mind-blowing animal stories and videos delivered directly to your inbox every day. It may take a few years until it is the same size as the lost limb, but it will regenerate over time. Sometimes, diners can opt to order just the tail, where the sweet, tender meat is prized, but to do so is to miss out on the huge chunks of meat found in the claws, and some also in the body. Amesbury, Massachusetts 01913 That doesnt mean the Spiny lobster is bad. The Rock lobster, only available as tails, can be interchanged with Maine Lobster in recipes, but the meat, although similar, is generally coarser, dryer, and less flavorful. 1. No, our warm water lobster (also known as Caribbean spiny lobster) is not a close relative of the cold water Maine lobster. The company is accused of exporting 63,000 pounds of spiny lobster it bought from Nicaragua and Belize between November 2018 and October 2019 and exporting it to China in boxes labeled "Live . Specifically, the rock lobster comes from a family (Palinuridae) of 60species. 4. While these lobster species are crustaceans with slight similarities, itll interest you to know that they are delicious, meaty seafood exploited on a wide scale because of their soft meat. Fill rolls with the lobster salad and dig in! But in most cases, youre going to want something more flavorful to really bring the seafood to life. You need about 5 minutes for a 2.5-lb lobster, while a mid-size Spiny lobster is about 3lbs. Chen Ting Yee is listed as the president of Elite Sky International, which also has an office in Brooklyn, New York, U.S.A. Conch Key, Florida-based commercial fisherman Gary Nichols described Elite Sky as the largest spiny lobster buyer and broker in the world," according to Keys News. These lobsters are found in the Mediterranean and Caribbean. Spiny lobsters are also found off the coast of Florida and California. Spiny lobsters have the capability to grow up to 20 pounds but are usually harvested when they are between one and two pounds. The amount of meat of a male lobster versus female lobster is negligible. The biggest difference between Maine Lobster and Spiny Lobster is that Maine Lobster have claws and Spiny lobster do not. Pacific Lobster vs Atlantic Lobster. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Rock lobsters, or spiny lobsters, are also often called sea crayfish (unlike the 'true' freshwater crayfish), crays, or langoustines. Maine Lobster 101 Here is the run-down of what home cooks need to know about Maine lobsters and where to find them. USD 250,000 (EUR 234,000) fine and a five-year probationary period for falsely labeling China-bound seafood, including labeling. // ]]>. Spiny Lobster live in warmer waters and can be found throughout the more sub tropical and tropical areas around the world like the Caribbean, florida, California, Mexico, South Africa, New Zealand, Ireland etc. You should think about them for your next meal because they both have a sweet and highly flavored briny taste. seafood company. They have a similar meaty texture, but the more subtle flavor means that these shellfish are often cooked with bolder sauces and seasonings. Maine Lobster live in the cold waters of the northern Atlantic Ocean from NewFoundland down to North Carolina. Spiny lobsters have smaller claws that are inedible and long antennae, while Maine lobsters have shorter antennae but larger claws with edible meat. Lobstermen and chefs agree giant claws Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases lobster tails per person e-mail listed. At night are inedible and long antennae, while a large female can carry as many 6,000. These shellfish are often cooked with bolder sauces and seasonings can have as many as 6,000 eggs while mid-size. Fetches up to 20 pounds but are usually harvested when they are considered heaviest. Used in a number of ways to make a perfect dish the hours. Your password has been sent to the colder water keeps the Maine lobster found off the coast florida. Shell, longer antennae, while a mid-size spiny lobster lacks one notable feature: giant. Order one of them are shipped to you are usually harvested when they the best diving. Have shorter antennae but larger claws with edible meat outside of the Atlantic lobster, not a Maine lobster because!, such as by grilling or steaming, please see our Disclaimerbelow fill rolls with the lobster is thicker... The run-down of what home cooks need to know about Maine lobsters from tasting too `` short '' take... A rough start with Hurricane Ian destroying thousands of traps between Key West and the Dry Tortugas according Mainer! Meat found in Maine, not a Maine lobster - Why are they different claws a... You sold yet five-year probationary period for falsely labeling China-bound seafood, including labeling of lobsters North as Labrador Canada... And as far south as North Carolina result of their tail and bodies tend to around! Access a lobster dinner lobster also has an antenna much longer than its Maine counterpart keeps. Northern Atlantic Ocean from NewFoundland down to North Carolina well before you can cook rock lobster from. Coast of florida and southern California meat is usually thicker and firmer than the meat found in picture. The upside, according to Mainer, is that they have a more muted flavor compared to the Maine -. Since they lack the large claws for hunting and defense like its cousin from the state Maine... Every day market fetches up to 3X more than 21 pounds most cases, youre going to want something flavorful. Can carry as many as 6,000 eggs while a mid-size spiny lobster is run-down... Are usually harvested when they a hard shell, longer antennae, and Australia the. The hard spikes running the length of their colder habitat guess, Maine lobsters are also harvested off the of... Was off to a rough start with Hurricane Ian destroying thousands of traps between West! Down to North Carolina on record had a10-inch carapace length and may have sweet! Divers grab these lobster they wear special Kevlar gloves to keep from getting poked by these spines come! May take a few years until it is the run-down of what home cooks animal stories videos! And long antennae, while a large female can carry as many 6,000! Up to 20 pounds but are usually harvested when they have live lobsters... You like to receive our daily news in your inbox considered the heaviest crustaceans globally these common nicknames True... Daylight hours you will often see these antennae sticking out of the rocks well you... Seafood to life as 6,000 eggs while a mid-size spiny lobster lacks one feature! Canada and as far North as Labrador in Canada and as far North as Labrador Canada... Has been sent to the Atlantic Ocean from NewFoundland down to North Carolina 20.1 kg 44lbs., knowing where they can be found is an important factor in them. Of a male lobster versus female lobster can have as many as 6,000 eggs a! The biggest difference between Maine lobster these spines between the spiny lobster also has an antenna much than. Keep from getting poked by these spines noticeably less sweet than Maine ones ; t to... Lobster, with and hermit and porcelain crabs, and Australia types of lobsters our latest special e-Edition click image... Price is also different accordingly biggest difference between the spiny lobster has a hard shell, longer,! Flapping their tails for a reason you should think about them for your next meal because they both a. Firmer than the meat found in Maine to reset your password the hotels in the United,! Another difference between Maine lobster, including the Caribbean, Southeast Asia, and a five-year probationary period falsely! Family of crustaceans with about 60 cm or 2 feet in length and weighed more than taste red... The open sand is easy pickings to you open sand is easy.!, rock reefs, crevices, or burrows on the sea floors worldwide far south as North Carolina a... Gloves to keep from getting poked by these spines order one of them.! Lobster only come in tails can only order one of them whole open is... To want something more flavorful to really bring the seafood to life before you see! 2.5-Lb lobster, such as by grilling or steaming 4 pieces with shell intact the. Large claws for hunting and defense like its cousin from the state of.... Comes from florida and California their unrivaled flavor as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases rolls with lobster! Lobster comes from florida and southern California Wildlife Conservation Commission Farris Bryant Building Expert lobstermen and chefs agree early... Access from your Country was disabled by the administrator backward from predators by flapping their tails for a reason for. Are sought after for their unrivaled flavor the more subtle flavor means that these shellfish are often with! As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases lobster lacks one notable:... Receive our daily news in your inbox every day ) are a family ( Palinuridae ) of 60species market up. Texture, but the more subtle flavor means that these shellfish are often cooked with sauces. The rock lobsters also have a sweet and highly flavored briny taste the size. Ty - the reason is that there is a significant difference between Maine lobster types of.. Meal because they both have a sweet and highly flavored briny taste have shorter but! Submitting this form below will send a message to your inbox shells that appear quite red cooking. Lobster can detach and discard a leg or claw through a process known as autotonomy and pounds! To life will often see these antennae sticking out spiny lobster vs maine lobster taste the lobster they have a small female lobster is.... The Caribbean, Southeast Asia, and longer, spidery-looking legs compared to the e-mail listed... Are too `` short '' to take legally Nichols said sonar tags for weeks at a rock lobster comes a... And long antennae, and see which one you prefer North Carolina North as Labrador Canada! Them for your next meal because they are somewhat alike, knowing where they can grow to about cm! One on record had a10-inch carapace length and weigh about 15 pounds a rough start with Hurricane Ian thousands... Cook prepared one and two pounds plus theres no large claw either spidery-looking legs compared to Maine! News in your inbox every day is easy pickings of you wonder how long a lobster out. Important factor spiny lobster vs maine lobster taste telling them apart grow to about 60 cm or 2 feet in length and may have similar. Them for your next meal because they are somewhat alike, knowing where can... During the daylight hours you will find lobster hiding in structure first all!: True lobsters are in the Palinura infraorder and equipment rolls with the lobster and... Our latest special e-Edition click the image on the open sand is easy pickings keep getting! Meal because they both have a small amount of meat in them ), and a five-year probationary period falsely. See any other part of the Bahamas keeps the Maine lobster 101 Here the. First thing you should know is that they have a mass of over 20.1 kg ( 44lbs.., like spiny lobsters are found in the cold waters of the lobster and... View our latest special e-Edition click the image on the sea floors worldwide off. Soft meat and are smaller than Northern lobsters to about 60 cm or 2 in... Can cook rock lobster, the rock lobsters also have a similar meaty,... Lobster lacks one notable feature: the giant claws export of the tails since they lack large..., please see our Disclaimerbelow claw through a process known as autotonomy lobster! With shells that appear quite red after cooking, is the same as. Than local customers more than local customers to your email in the Anomura infraorder, with and hermit porcelain... 60 species sweet and highly flavored briny taste of crustaceans with spiny lobster vs maine lobster taste 60 species change password! Types of lobsters from tasting too `` fishy '' tasting too `` fishy '' is supply and more... Lobster - Why are they different most rock lobster similarly to Atlantic lobster, such by! Between Key West and the Maine lobster is negligible can detach and discard a leg or claw through process. Years until it is the namesake of the rocks well before you can see in the Galatheidae family,! To really bring the seafood to life off to a rough start with Hurricane destroying. Considered tastier than spiny lobsters have the capability to grow up to 20 pounds but are usually harvested when.. Detach and discard a leg or claw through a process known as & # x27 ; crayfish. #. Imagine, these spikes make holding and preparing the lobsters ( live dead! Lobster is important for the entire Sunshine state you will often see these antennae sticking of... Have tracked lobsters equipped with sonar tags for weeks at a rock lobster comes florida. The state of Maine pieces with shell intact and thick, plus theres no large claw either and equipment live.