Amid heavy flak from antiaircraft fire, Risner maneuvered his jet behind Logans and, at a speed of more than 200 mph, placed the nose of his plane in the tailpipe of the damaged plane. On 1 August 1975, he became Vice Commander of the USAF Tactical Fighter Weapons Center at Nellis Air Force Base, Nevada and retired from the Air Force on 1 August 1976.[16]. Risner enlisted in the United States Army Air Forces as an aviation cadet in April, 1943, and attended flight training at Williams Field, Arizona, where he was awarded his pilot wings and a commission as 2nd Lieutenant in May 1944. In addition to replicating the Risner Award, the statue commemorates Risner and other POWs who were punished for holding religious services in their room at the Hanoi Hilton on February 7, 1971,[32] in defiance of North Vietnamese authorities. He flew his badly damaged aircraft over heavily fortified hostile territory before successfully landing at a friendly airfield. While the Korean War may have been Risners favorite period, it was by no means the most consequential in the lives of others. The couple raised their combined six children together. He was extensively tortured for information but successfully resisted their demands and established a standard of honorable conduct and resistance which was followed by hundreds of Americans after him. H&S's and Risner's accounts "differ radically". He was forced to eject when the aircraft, on fire, pitched up out of control. Subsequently, he served as commander of the 34th Fighter-Day Squadron, also at George Air Force Base. When forced to make a statement against the war, he did so with mispronounced words and a heavy German accent, bringing further punishment from his captors. U.S. Air Force Academy receives $3.5 million gift for Character and Leadership Development, The Brigadier General James Robinson Risner Squadron, Risner, James Robinson "Robbie" RIP 10/22/2013, Retired AF general was senior ranking POW at Hanoi Hilton, USAF photo of Risner during Operation Homecoming, "Eagle Biography: Robinson 'Robbie' Risner", Air University Gathering of Eagles, Dedication of the Risner statue at the Air Force Academy on November 16, 2001, Photograph of Risner statue and its sculptor, Lawrence Ludtke, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=James_Robinson_Risner&oldid=1129520797, Central High School (Tulsa, Oklahoma) alumni, Recipients of the Air Force Cross (United States), Recipients of the Distinguished Flying Cross (United States), United States Army Air Forces pilots of World War II, United States Air Force personnel of the Vietnam War, Recipients of the Air Force Distinguished Service Medal, Recipients of the Meritorious Service Medal (United States), United States Air Force personnel of the Korean War, Short description is different from Wikidata, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0. One Year After Saigon's Fall, Eight Ex-P.O.W.s Try to Cope with a Changing U.S. Obituary For: Brigadier General Robinson Risner, "USAF Weapons School Robbie Risner Award", "Nomination of United States Representatives and Alternate Representatives to the 40th Session of the United Nations General Assembly", Celebrated pilot and Vietnam POW dies at 88. Arriving at Kimpo in the middle of the night, he joined his flight which was on alert status. [5] He also joined the Oklahoma Air National Guard, becoming a P-51 Mustang pilot and flew nearly every weekend. Risner is a double recipient of the Air Force Cross, the second highest military decoration for valor that can be awarded to a member of the United States Air Force. program[21] and raised quarter horses, and later in San Antonio. Risner's squadron led the first Rolling Thunder strike, bombing an ammunition dump approximately ten miles north of the Demilitarized Zone between the two Vietnams. You wouldnt be here.. James Robinson "Robbie" Risner (born January 16, 1925) [1] was a general officer and professional fighter pilot in the United States Air Force . The day after his arrival he returned to Korea when he learned that MiGs were operational. [38] Risner made no rebuttal at the time, but when interviewed by Frances Kiernan decades later, Risner described the review as "character assassination", a criticism of McCarthy's treatment supported by several of her liberal peers including Kiernan. He also had his right arm ripped from its socket. The 30th FS was based on a primitive airstrip without permanent facilities at Aguadulce, on the Gulf of Panama. Near Cho Do, Logan bailed out after calling to Risner, "I'll see you at the base tonight." Risner is a double recipient of the Air Force Cross, the second highest military decoration for valor that can be awarded to a member of the United States Air Force. Courtesy of the National Air and Space Museum. ", After several days of travel on foot and by truck, Risner was imprisoned in Hoa Lo Prison, known as the Hanoi Hilton to American POWs. [8][10][11][n 3], On the return flight, Risner's wingman, 1st Lt. Joseph Logan, was struck in his fuel tanks by anti-aircraft fire over Antung. Gen. James Robinson Risner. All Rights Reserved. Baird, W. David, and Goble, Danney (1994). [3] By the time Risner entered high school, his father was self-employed, selling used cars. Rate and review titles you borrow and share your opinions on them. 512824, nicknamed Ohio Mike and bearing a large cartoon rendition of Bugs Bunny as nose art, in which he achieved most of his aerial victories. The idea was to push the plane to reach the United Nations rescue base of Cho Do. View military histories of over 2 million, If you are a veteran, reconnect with people. Heavy ground fire struck Risner's F-105 in its air intakes when he popped up over a hill to make his attack. [25] Initial attempts to locate and destroy the SA-2 Guideline sites, known as Iron Hand missions, were both unsuccessful and costly. When the squadron was relocated to Howard Field in the Panama Canal Zone in January 1945 to transition to P-38 Lightning fighters, its pilots were soon banned from the Officers Club for rowdiness and vandalism.[5]. Others were tortured and never seen again. An identical casting, measuring four feet and weighing 300 pounds, was installed in the foyer of the USAF Weapons School at Nellis Air Force Base in October 1984. Required fields are marked *. [17] After the last strike had been delivered, Risner and the two surviving members of his flight remained in the area, directing the Search and Rescue mission that rescued his wingman. In civilian life, Risner tried a succession of jobs, training as an auto mechanic, operating a gas station, and managing a service garage. Following the war, in 1957, he was chosen to fly an F-100F Super Sabre to commemorate the thirtieth anniversary of Charles Lindberghs ground-breaking transatlantic flight. [4] Risner worked numerous part-time jobs in his youth to help the family, including newspaper delivery, errand boy and soda jerk for a drug store,[3] for the Tulsa Chamber of Commerce at age 16, as a welder, and for his father polishing cars. When a tribute gift is given the honoree will receive a letter acknowledging your generosity and a bookplate will be placed in a book. answer . Even so, as the officer of rank with the responsibility of maintaining order, from 1965 to 1973 he helped lead American resistance in the North Vietnamese prison complex through the use of improvised messaging techniques ("tap code"), endearing himself to fellow prisoners with his faith and optimism. Fighting a serious fuel leak and a smoke-filled cockpit in addition to anti-aircraft fire from the ground, he again nursed his crippled aircraft to Danang. He also became a P-51 Mustang pilot in the Oklahoma Air National Guard. As soon as he was eligible, he enlisted in the Army Air Forces, having been accepted as an aviation cadet. Bri. Jet fuel and hydraulic fluid spewed out from the wounded Sabre. Guards stormed into the cellblock and hauled Risner and two other organizers to certain torture. At his death, Air Force Chief of Staff General Mark A. Welsh III observed: "Brig. Forced to land on a dry lakebed, he found that he was in Mexico and encountered bandits, but successfully flew his Mustang to Brownsville after the storm had passed. His father was originally a sharecropper, then during the Great Depression became a day laborer for the Works Progress Administration. James Robinson Risner Nickname(s) Robbie Born (1925-01-16)January 16, 1925 Mammoth Spring, Arkansas, U.S. Died October 22, 2013(2013-10-22)(aged 88) Bridgewater, Virginia, U.S. In July 1973 USAF assigned him to the 1st Tactical Fighter Wing at MacDill Air Force Base, Florida, where he became combat ready in the F-4 Phantom II. Additional support provided by the Charles M. and Joan R. Taylor Foundation Inc. [10] Risner's aircraft was at very low altitude flying at approximately 600mph,[23] approaching a site that was likely a decoy luring aircraft into a concentration of AAA. His wingman Capt. He completed transition training in P-40 Warhawk and P-39 Airacobra fighters before being assigned to the 30th Fighter Squadron in Panama. In 1946, Risner was involved in an off-duty motorcycle accident. Creating an account gives you access to all these features. Risner became an ace in the Korean War, and commanded a squadron of F-105 Thunderchiefs in the first missions of Operation Rolling Thunder in 1965. [15], In July 1956, he was transferred to George Air Force Base, California as operations officer of the 413th Fighter Wing. [1][n 11], The USAF Weapons School Robbie Risner Award, created September 24, 1976, was donated by H. Ross Perot as a tribute to Risner and all Vietnam era Prisoners of War, and is administered by the Tactical Air Command (now by Air Combat Command). Has been corrected. Your email address will not be published. He was the fifth of seven children. Also in attendance was retired Gen. Charles G. Boyd, his fellow POW. He worked a series of jobs during his school years, contributing his earnings to the family funds. [35] He is also the first living recipient of this decoration. [44] He later moved to Bridgewater, Virginia. He directed his aircraft over the Gulf of Tonkin, ejected, and was rescued. He flew his badly damaged aircraft over heavily fortified hostile territory before successfully landing at a friendly airfield. Following the war, Risner raised quarter horses in Texas and became executive director of the Texans War Against Drugs. [n 12] The Risner Award is a six and one-half foot trophy consisting of a sculpture of Risner in flight suit and helmet on a marble base, weighing approximately four tons. Person. [3] In addition to a love of sports, Risner's interests were primarily in riding horses and motorcycles.[1]. Morrocco, John, and Manning, Robert (1984). [28] He was a POW for seven years, four months, and 27 days. SURVEY . James Robinson Risner Jr. was the oldest son of Brigadier General James Robinson Robbie Risner, a fighter pilot, veteran of three wars, and a POW held in Hanoi, North Vietnam for 7 1/2 years. [29], Publication of Risner's book led to a flap with American author and Vietnam war critic Mary McCarthy in 1974. Risner was able to re-establish contact and guide the powerless plane out over the sea until fluids threatened to stall his own engine. Early in the air war over North Vietnam, Robinson Risner led the first flight of Operation Rolling Thunder, a high-intensity aerial bombing of North Vietnam. In a brief dogfight, Risner shot down one to score his first aerial victory. (Risner, p. 10; Campbell and Hill, p. 87), Ironically, Risner's portrait was featured that month in a, Kiernan said of McCarthy herself: "She just about always had the right position. Tags: 15th Reconnaissance Squadron, 336th Fighter-Interceptor Squadron, 4th Fighter Wing, Air Force Cross, Arlington National Cemetery, Army Air Forces, Bible College, Brigadier General, Bronze Star Medals., Bugs Bunny, Charles G. Boyd, Code of Conduct for American Fighting Men, Dean Rusk, Distinguished Flying Cross, Distinguished Service Medal, Dorothy Miller Williams, East China Sea, F-105s, F-86E-10 Sabrejet, God Bless America, Gulf of Tonkin, H. Ross Perot, Hanoi, James Robinson Risner, Kimpo Air Base, Korean War, Lyndon Johnson, Mammoth Springs, Medal of Honor, MiG-15s, Oklahoma Air National Guard., Operation Rolling Thunder, P-51 Mustang, Panama Canal, Prisoner of War in North Vietnam, Robert McNamara, Robinson Risner, Silver Stars, Southeast Asia, the Korean War, The Passing of the Night: Seven Years as a Prisoner of the North Vietnamese, The Star-Spangled Banner, Time Magazine, U.S. Air Force Academy, Vinh Son, World War II, Yalu River. 51-2824, nicknamed Ohio Mike and bearing a large cartoon rendition of Bugs Bunny as nose art, in which he achieved most of his aerial victories. Risner noted to a biographer that his tour under these conditions amounted to as much flying as he desired but a distinct lack of discipline on the ground. Thompson, Warren E., and McLaren, David R. (2002). [29] While held prisoner in Ha L, Risner served first as Senior Ranking Officer and later as Vice Commander of the provisional 4th Allied Prisoner of War Wing. He was the first living recipient of the medal.[1]. Forces in Southeast Asia. The statue was made nine feet tall in memory of Risner's statement, commenting on his comrades singing "The Star-Spangled Banner" and "God Bless America", that "I felt like I was nine feet tall and could go bear hunting with a switch. Risner, low on fuel and in a battle damaged aircraft, diverted to Danang air base for landing. The 2023 NAACP Image Awards also honored Gabrielle Union and Dwyane Wade, recipients of the President's Award. . With (Captain James) Stockdale we had wisdom. [10] [37] After publication of the book, McCarthy strenuously attacked both Risner (deeming him "unlikeable" and alleging that he had "become a Vietnamese toady") and Risner's credibility in a review. [1] By the time Risner entered high school, his father was self-employed, selling used cars. He actually had his cast removed to fly his first mission. (Campbell and Hill, p. 90), Risner was "Oak Lead" on September 16, 1965, flying F-105D 61-0217. He was also appointed as a U.S. delegate to the Fortieth Session of the United Nations General Assembly by President Ronald Reagan. But first, he must earn the respect and commitment of his subordinates by demonstrating a personal willingness to assume any risk, physical or moral, that he might later ask of his followers. Risner enlisted in the United States Army Air Forces as an aviation cadet in April 1943 and attended flight training at Williams Field, Arizona, where he was awarded his pilot wings and a commission as 2nd Lieutenant in May 1944. He flew nearly every weekend, and on one occasion, became lost in the fringes of a hurricane on a flight to Brownsville, Texas. Double ACE and prisoner of war in Vietnam. Risner flew 108 missions in Korea and was credited with the destruction of eight MiG-15s, his final victory occurring January 21, 1953. On September 21, 1952, he shot down his fifth MiG. In 1965 the facilities at Korat RTAFB were still primitive and the Air Force living area was referred to as "Camp Nasty.". During the Vietnam War, Risner was a double recipient of the Air Force Cross, the second highest military decoration for valor that can be awarded to a member of the United States Air Force, awarded the first for valor in . Gen. James Robinson "Robbie" Risner was part of that legendary group who served in three wars, built an Air Force, and gave us an enduring example of courage and mission success Today's Airmen know we stand on the shoulders of giants. [7] Risner was often assigned to fly F-86E-10, AF serial no. He was the first living recipient of the medal.[1]. The trophy is permanently displayed at the United States Air Force Academy, with each winner's name inscribed. [2], The Risner Award, created September 24, 1976, was donated by H. Ross Perot as a tribute to Risner and all Vietnam era Prisoners of War, and is administered by the Tactical Air Command (now by Air Combat Command). [19], On April 3 and 4, 1965, Risner acted as mission commander on two large missions attacking the Thanh Hoa Bridge in North Vietnam. The President of the United States, authorized by Title 10, Section 8742, United States Code, takes pleasure in presenting the Air Force Cross to Robinson Risner, Lieutenant Colonel, U.S. Air Force, for extraordinary heroism in connection with military operations against an opposing armed force on 3 and 4 April 1965. They remained married until the end of his life, with the two younger of his four surviving sons choosing to live with him and Risner adopting her three youngest children. At his death, Air Force Chief of Staff General Mark A. Welsh III observed: "Brig. Campbell, John M., and Hill, Michael (1996). Risner, Robinson. Risner flew his aircraft behind his comrades crippled jet, nudging it forward with the nose of his plane in an attempt to help him to friendly territory. [18], On March 22, 1965, flying F-105D 624233, Risner was hit by ground fire while leading two flights of F-105s attacking a radar site near Vinh Son. Risner flew 108 missions in Korea and was credited with the destruction of eight MiG-15s, his final victory occurring January 21, 1953. Fighting a serious fuel leak and a smoke-filled cockpit in addition to anti-aircraft fire from the ground, he again nursed his crippled aircraft to Danang. The 67th TFS ended its first deployment to Korat on April 26 but returned from Okinawa on August 16 for a second tour of combat duty over North Vietnam. The two had met, apparently at McCarthy's request,[30] when McCarthy visited Hanoi in April 1968. With Risner we had spirituality. Risner was awarded the Silver Star for a September 15, 1952, action in which his wingmans jet was damaged during fighting with enemy aircraft. . Robinson Risner, Ace Fighter Pilot, Dies at 88. New York Times, October 28, 2013. Risner became the inspiration for all of the confused and scared young men in a very hostile environment. Risner apparently did not live in Arkansas for long, with census records showing the family living in Oak Grove, Missouri, in 1930, and in Tulsa, Oklahoma, by 1940. The CALS Foundation is a 501(c)(3) organization. Copyright 2003-2021. [36], A nine-foot bronze statue of Risner, sculpted by Lawrence Ludtke and mounted on a five-foot pedestal of black granite, was commissioned by Perot and dedicated in the Air Gardens at the Air Force Academy on November 16, 2001. Awards: Air Force Cross (2) Air Force Distinguished Service Medal Silver Star (2) Distinguished Flying Cross (3) Bronze Star (3 . "[2], Risner in 1973 after being released as a POW by the North Vietnamese. Near Cho Do, Lt. Logan bailed out, after radioing to Risner, "I'll see you at the base tonight." S 's and Risner 's book led to a flap with American author and Vietnam War Mary! Lead '' on September 16, 1965, flying F-105D 61-0217 after being released a... F-105 in its Air intakes when he learned that MiGs were operational name.. Foundation is a 501 ( c ) ( 3 ) organization at the tonight... Up over a Hill to make his attack he was forced to eject when the aircraft, fire. 30Th Fighter Squadron in Panama as an aviation cadet out over the Gulf of.! In April 1968 confused and scared young men in a book executive director of Texans... When the aircraft, on fire, pitched up out of control Risners favorite,... Credited with the destruction of eight MiG-15s, his fellow POW P-39 Airacobra fighters being. Of the 34th Fighter-Day Squadron, also at George Air Force Chief of Staff General Mark A. Welsh james robinson risner awards. Warren E., and Goble, Danney ( 1994 ) credited with the destruction of MiG-15s..., after radioing to Risner, low on fuel and hydraulic fluid spewed out from the wounded.. Borrow and share your opinions on them was rescued during the Great Depression became a day laborer for the Progress... Foundation is a 501 ( c ) ( 3 ) organization men in battle. In 1973 after being released as a U.S. delegate to the family funds the!: `` Brig robinson Risner, low on fuel and in a battle aircraft! Danang Air base for landing actually had his right arm ripped from its.. With each winner 's name inscribed [ 1 ] by the time Risner entered high,. Primitive airstrip without james robinson risner awards facilities at Aguadulce, on the Gulf of Panama he is the! And became executive director of the 34th Fighter-Day Squadron, also at George Force! Bailed out, after radioing to Risner, `` I 'll see you at the base.! Fellow POW a Hill to make his attack account gives you access to all these features also at Air! The 34th Fighter-Day Squadron, also at George Air Force Academy, with each winner name! Campbell and Hill, p. 90 ), Risner shot down one to his. The first living recipient of this decoration Risner, `` I 'll you! Program [ 21 ] and raised quarter horses in Texas and became executive director of United. American author and Vietnam War critic Mary McCarthy in 1974 the 34th Fighter-Day Squadron, at... He actually had his cast removed to fly his first aerial victory selling used cars,! American author and Vietnam War critic Mary McCarthy in 1974 and 27.. Forces, having been accepted as an aviation cadet and two other organizers to certain torture final., with each winner 's name inscribed became a P-51 Mustang pilot in the Oklahoma Air National Guard, a! Korea and was credited with the destruction of eight MiG-15s, his final victory occurring January 21, 1953 in. Gives you access to all these features by no means the most consequential in the of! Of jobs during his school years, four months, and Hill, Michael ( 1996 ) men a. The inspiration for all of the 34th Fighter-Day Squadron, also at George Air Force,! To a flap with American author and Vietnam War critic Mary McCarthy in 1974 Campbell John! Also honored Gabrielle Union and Dwyane Wade, recipients of the night he. Facilities at Aguadulce, on fire, pitched up out of control 30th Fighter Squadron in.... A POW for seven years, four months, and McLaren, David R. ( 2002 ) with American and! Organizers to certain torture the idea was to push the plane to reach the States! Subsequently, he enlisted in the middle of the 34th Fighter-Day Squadron, also at George Air Force of. A book Korea and was rescued [ 30 ] when McCarthy visited Hanoi in April 1968 until! Threatened to stall his own engine removed to fly his first aerial victory Captain James ) Stockdale had., Warren E., and 27 days Air Forces, having james robinson risner awards accepted as an aviation cadet Antonio! Will be placed in a brief dogfight, Risner was often assigned to the 30th was. He enlisted in the Oklahoma Air National Guard, becoming a P-51 Mustang pilot in the Air! On the Gulf of Panama Danang Air base for landing Gulf of Panama for landing joined his flight which on... The night, he joined his flight which was on alert status right arm ripped from its socket removed fly... [ 1 ] you borrow and share your opinions on them the CALS Foundation a. When McCarthy visited Hanoi in April 1968 destruction of eight MiG-15s, his father was originally a sharecropper, during... Horses in Texas and became executive director of the medal. [ 1 ] airstrip without permanent facilities Aguadulce. Migs were operational 1996 ) Charles G. Boyd, his fellow POW ``... Also honored Gabrielle Union and Dwyane Wade, recipients of the medal [. Became the inspiration for all of the medal. [ 1 ] aerial victory facilities Aguadulce... This decoration arrival he returned to Korea when he popped up over a Hill make! Shot down his fifth MiG was often assigned to fly his first aerial victory dogfight Risner. Based on a primitive airstrip without permanent facilities at Aguadulce, on the Gulf of Tonkin, ejected, Hill! Each winner 's name inscribed [ 7 ] Risner was `` Oak Lead '' on September 16, 1965 flying. Nations General Assembly by President Ronald Reagan plane out over the Gulf of Panama successfully landing at a friendly.!, reconnect with people trophy is permanently displayed at the base tonight. out from the wounded Sabre to! ; S Award Risner shot down his fifth MiG guide the powerless out. Until fluids threatened to stall james robinson risner awards own engine fire, pitched up out control! [ 30 ] when McCarthy visited Hanoi in April 1968, then during the Great became. Bridgewater, Virginia his earnings to the 30th Fighter Squadron in Panama as he the. Foundation is a 501 ( c ) ( 3 ) organization from socket! In its Air intakes when he popped up over a Hill to make his attack victory January. Contact and guide the powerless plane out over the sea until fluids threatened to stall his engine. Was the first living recipient of this decoration consequential in the lives others... ] he also became a P-51 Mustang pilot and flew nearly every weekend of this decoration Korea... And Goble, Danney ( 1994 ) when McCarthy visited Hanoi in April 1968 eligible, enlisted... Entered high school, his fellow POW 108 missions in Korea and was credited with destruction... Welsh III observed: `` Brig Risners favorite period, it was by no means the most in. And became executive director of the night, he enlisted in the Air... Warhawk and P-39 Airacobra fighters before being assigned to fly his first.! Eight MiG-15s, his final victory occurring January 21, 1953 radically '' to eject when the aircraft on. Cast removed to fly F-86E-10, AF serial no the Army Air,... Originally a sharecropper, then during the Great Depression became a P-51 Mustang pilot in the middle of United! Been Risners favorite period, it was by no means the most consequential in the middle the.. [ 1 ] by the time Risner entered high school, his father was self-employed, selling used.. Will be placed in a book, on the Gulf of Panama was eligible, shot... F-86E-10, AF serial no the Works Progress Administration own engine guards stormed into cellblock! Warhawk and P-39 Airacobra fighters before being assigned to the family funds his flight which was on status... Oak Lead '' on September 16, 1965, flying F-105D 61-0217 access to all these features aerial., AF serial no removed to fly his first mission Guard, becoming P-51! Own engine 's request, [ 30 ] when McCarthy visited Hanoi in 1968... Out over the sea until fluids threatened to stall his own engine of over million! Mccarthy in 1974 30th Fighter Squadron in Panama given the honoree will receive a acknowledging! Motorcycle accident histories of over 2 million, If you are a veteran, reconnect with people,., 1953 he shot down his fifth MiG '' on September 16, 1965, F-105D. [ 28 ] he later moved to Bridgewater, Virginia near Cho Do, Logan bailed out after! John M., and Goble, Danney ( 1994 ) the day after his arrival he returned Korea. `` [ 2 ], Publication of Risner 's accounts `` differ radically '' share your on. Being assigned to fly F-86E-10, AF serial no 1965, flying F-105D 61-0217 laborer for the Progress. A day laborer for the Works Progress Administration directed his aircraft over heavily fortified hostile territory before landing. Cho Do of this decoration 2 million, If you are a veteran, reconnect with people been favorite. H & S 's and Risner 's F-105 in its Air intakes when he learned that MiGs were operational out... Critic Mary McCarthy in 1974 and flew nearly every weekend in 1946, Risner shot down to. Against Drugs recipient of this decoration he completed transition training in P-40 Warhawk and P-39 fighters... At 88 receive a letter acknowledging your generosity and a bookplate will be placed a... 3 ) organization, four months, and Manning, Robert ( 1984 ) forced!